Antique Cut Diamonds: A Timeless Elegance – Old Mine & Old European Cuts

Antique-cut diamonds, specifically the Old Mine Cut and Old European Cut, are rich in history and offer a distinct, vintage charm that modern brilliant cuts cannot replicate. These hand-cut diamonds from the 18th and 19th centuriesreflect a bygone era of craftsmanship, showcasing larger facets, softer sparkle, and romantic imperfections. Whether you’re a lover of vintage jewelry or seeking an engagement ring with historical significance, antique-cut diamonds are truly one of a kind.

What Are Antique Cut Diamonds?

Antique-cut diamonds were cut by hand, without modern technology, resulting in unique, non-uniform facets that give each stone a distinctive character and a softer, candlelit glow. The two most popular antique diamond cuts are:

  1. Old Mine Cut (Early 1700s–Late 1800s)
  2. Old European Cut (Late 1800s–Early 1900s)

Unlike modern round brilliant diamonds, which maximize light return and sparkle, these antique diamonds were cut to glow beautifully under candlelight, giving them an inherently romantic allure.

Growing Demand for Old Mine Cut Diamonds

Due to the increased demand for Old Mine Cut diamonds, diamond dealers have started to cut new diamonds into these shapes in order to meet the rising interest. At Benz & Co Diamonds, we also cut both natural and lab-grown diamonds into Old Mine Cut styles, giving our customers the option to own an Old Mine Cut diamond while maintaining affordability and exceptional quality.

Old Mine Cut Diamonds – The Predecessor of the Modern Cushion Cut

The Old Mine Cut is one of the oldest diamond shapes, first appearing in the early 1700s. It was the most common cut until the late 1800s and is recognized by its square-to-rectangular shape with rounded corners.

Key Features of Old Mine Cut Diamonds:

✔ Hand-cut facets – Each diamond has unique proportions, making no two exactly alike.
✔ Chunky facets – Larger facets create a soft, romantic glow rather than intense brilliance.
✔ Small table and high crown – Results in a domed top, enhancing depth and warmth.
✔ Deep pavilion – Adds to the rich, fiery sparkle of the stone.
✔ Slightly asymmetrical – Gives a charming, old-world appearance.

Why Choose an Old Mine Cut?

  • A true piece of history – Originating in the Georgian and Victorian eras, these diamonds offer a glimpse into the past.
  • Unique, non-uniform look – Unlike modern precision cuts, each stone has its own artistic character.
  • Warmer glow – The deep cut and high crown allow for a cozy, flickering light effect, perfect for vintage lovers.

Old European Cut Diamonds – The Grandfather of the Modern Round Brilliant

The Old European Cut (OEC) was developed in the late 1800s and became the standard diamond cut during the Victorian, Edwardian, and Art Deco eras. This cut evolved from the Old Mine Cut, maintaining the high crown and deep pavilion but with a rounder shape and improved symmetry.

Key Features of Old European Cut Diamonds:

✔ Rounded shape – The first attempt at a fully round diamond cut.
✔ Larger, open facets – Creates a softer, more romantic sparkle.
✔ Smaller table, higher crown – Results in a rich, deep fire that plays with light beautifully.
✔ Visible culet – The small flat facet at the bottom of the diamond is a signature of antique cuts.

Why Choose an Old European Cut?

  • Vintage appeal – Perfect for Art Deco and Edwardian-style engagement rings.
  • Romantic brilliance – Offers softer, more colorful sparkle compared to modern diamonds.
  • Sustainable and ethical – Antique diamonds require no new mining, making them an eco-friendly choice.

Celebrities with Antique-Cut Engagement Rings

Many celebrities have embraced the Old Mine Cut and Old European Cut for their engagement rings, appreciating their history, uniqueness, and romance.

  • Scarlett Johansson – Wears an 11-carat Old Cut diamond in an modern setting.

  • Miley Cyrus (from Liam Hemsworth) – Sported a 19th-century Old Mine Cut diamond set in yellow gold.

Choosing the Best Antique-Cut Diamond

When selecting an Old Mine Cut or Old European Cut diamond, there are key factors to consider:

1. Cut Quality & Shape

Since antique diamonds were hand-cut, expect slight asymmetry and unique proportions. Look for:
✔ A well-defined culet and a high crown.
✔ Symmetry in the lobes and shape for a balanced look.
✔ Depth and table percentages that enhance fire and brilliance.

2. Color Recommendations

Old Mine and Old European cuts tend to mask color better than modern cuts, making warmer-toned diamonds (J-K-L) still appear beautiful.

  • Lab-grown diamonds – G-H color appears bright white, while D-F offers a colorless, icy look.
  • Natural diamonds – I-J color can still look beautiful, especially in yellow or rose gold settings, while D-H remains the safest colorless to near-colorless choice.

3. Clarity Considerations

Antique diamonds often have natural inclusions due to historical cutting techniques.
✔ VS1-VS2 clarity is ideal for ensuring eye-clean brilliance.
✔ SI1-SI2 clarity can still appear flawless if inclusions are positioned near the edges.

Best Settings for Antique Diamonds

Old Mine Cut and Old European Cut diamonds look stunning in vintage-inspired settings, such as:

✔ Filigree & Milgrain – Enhances the vintage charm.
✔ Bezel Setting – Provides protection while maintaining antique beauty.
✔ Halo Setting – Increases size appearance and brilliance.
✔ Two-Stone Solitaire Setting – Adds a modern twist to a classic style.
✔ Rose Gold & Yellow Gold Settings – Complements the warm glow of antique diamonds.

Why Choose an Antique-Cut Diamond from Benz & Co Diamonds?

At Benz & Co Diamonds, we offer an exclusive collection of Old Mine and Old European Cut engagement rings, featuring:
✔ Authentic antique and vintage-inspired diamonds with unmatched charm.
✔ Sustainable, ethical sourcing, no new mining required.
✔ The largest selection of ready-to-ship antique engagement rings, so you don’t have to wait.
✔ Competitive pricing, ensuring the best value without compromising quality.
✔ Easy financing options with Affirm, choose up to 36 monthly payments with rates as low as 0% APR.

Final Thoughts

The Old Mine Cut and Old European Cut diamonds are perfect for those who love history, romance, and vintage elegance. Whether you’re drawn to their warm candlelit glow, rich heritage, or unique craftsmanship, these antique diamonds offer something truly special.

Now, explore Benz & Co Diamonds' antique-cut engagement rings, where timeless beauty meets expert craftsmanship.

 

Back to blog